Tag Archives: Manchester City

Manchester City case “enters bullying stage”

Let’s get it right, Manchester City’s defence of the 115 was nothing short of a disaster.

114 of the 115 charges stuck, the Premier League labelled it a “sham”, and key witnesses and irrefutable evidence on behalf of Manchester City either did not materialise or could not be proven.

Manchester City’s sole defence of the entire situation is that it was not Abu Dhabi United Group (ADUG) that subsidised the huge sums paid to Man City by sponsors, But the Abu Dhabi Government (AD).

This line of defence directly contradicts what Etihad Airways told the US Government back in 2015.

And this is exactly why the Man City case has fallen the way it has.

Whilst City may have claimed that the sponsorship money was subsidised by AD, and not ADUG, they were unable to provide any evidence. Neither AD, Etihad, or alternative organisations would have been able to provide proof of where funding comes from because it would have completely contradicted that 2015 investigation.

City fans across social media are claiming that lawyers defence is “genius” and that they are playing 4D chess. This is laughable.

You do not go into a hearing, a court case, or anything else, with the aim of losing so that you can win on appeal. It does not happen. And it is ludicrous that anyone is claiming that City lawyers were hoping to lose so that they could “expose the Premier League on appeal”. Especially when you consider the cost of those lawyers.

High up executives at Man City, ADUG and AD know exactly the predicament they are in – and there only two paths out.

Man City or Etihad Airways. The will have to choose a fighter.

The evidence needed to exhonorate Man City throws Etihad under the bus with the US Government. 

If evidence is presented to show that Etihad were funded by AD, then the US will reopen their 2015 investigation. That could have huge implications for not only one of the biggest airlines in the world, who are also AD’s flagship brand, but also for those who presented the evidence in 2015.

Not only would presenting the evidence in support of City be an existential threat to Etihad, it would likely lead to criminal proceedings for those who then lied in the evidence above.

The alternative for AD is to back Etihad, and it is Man City who are then pushed under that bus.

Without AD or Etihad being willing to corroborate Man City’s claims, the Premier League can rightly disregard Man City’s claims of where the funding came from.

The question ultimately for AD is do they want to sacrifice Man City to the Premier League to protect Etihad, or do they want to sacrifice Etihad to the US Government in an attempt to protect Man City.

And that leads us to where we are now. The bullying stage.

AD and ADUG can not keep their two flagship operations clean. One will have to fall. So in an attempt to get two favourable outcomes, they are now using political, legal and PR posturing to bully the Premier League and UK Government.

Firstly we have Etihad threatening to sue the Premier League.

The headline is that they have hired “the world’s most feared litigation law firm” in Quinn Emanuel.

Firstly, the chances that they have only just hired Quinn Emanuel are laughable. Major companies like Etihad will likely have major global law firms on retainers. We’ve all watched Suits. We all know how this works.

Secondly, I am not really sure what the basis of any case by Etihad against the Premier League could be built on.

It is an independent commission panel that heard the case, and made the judgement. Not the Premier League. The PL merely presented their case, their evidence. And when it came to evidence around where the funding came from, everything that mentioned Etihad came from Man City or ADUG emails. You can no sue someone for presenting the facts as they appear.

If Etihad are to sue anyone, it would actually be Man City, as it is them that have made the claim that their sponsors, including Etihad, were subsidised by AD. If this as an untrue statement by Man City, then that is where the lawsuit sits.

As for the posturing by the UAE, there is zero chance that they will pull investment in the UK due to the decision against Manchester City.

A move like this would have huge ramifications across the globe. It would show to the world that the UAE and the Emirati that make it believe that they are above the law in whichever county they have organisations, companies or sports teams operating. It sends out a sign to governments worldwide that they believe their organisations can operate however they want, and if they are sanctioned then government level investment will be pulled.

This position is not a position of strength.

Whilst on the short term, the UK may lose out on investment, it would not be a catastrophe. 

In the grand scheme of things, the UAE is not one of the biggest investors in the UK. The are no where near the US, India or France. The billions they claim that they will pull from the UK is only around 0.3-1.4% of the foreign investment in the UK. Although it must be said that is public money. There is also a private side, such as the millions pumped into Manchester by ADUG.

Whilst pulling investment would not be catastrophic for the UK, it would be a catastrophic decision by the UAE. 

As we briefly outlined above, why would any foreign government want to do investment deals with the UAE if the UAE show themselves as willing do drop their investment due to one of their organisations have been sanctioned? It would lead governments being less willing to make deals with UAE. And we all know those deals are massive for the UAE as they attempt to invest the email money before the income dries up.

The estimation is that oil in the UAE will dry up in 80 years. Due to this they have a global investment strategy with the aim of reducing the reliance on oil – in 1980, 55% of the UAE GDP was based on oil, that is now just 23%.

UAE need to continue investing in both themselves (tourism) and foreign countries to ensure they survive once the oil runs out. If they fail to do so, the area will just become a desert. Pulling investment in the UK would directly damage this strategy, especially if other countries decide the UAE are no longer trustworthy enough to strike big deals with.

Etihad will not sue the PL. The UAE will not pull their investment in the UK. It is just bullying and PR.

The hope is to force the hand of the PL or UK Government into coming to a settlement. The aim is to also paint Man City as victims in all of this. To continue the sportswashing of the blue side of Manchester.

And whilst the bullying will not be successful, we are seeing the PR side of the project become a success. City fans from Manchester to Lagos, and across Asia are ignoring the facts and trying to paint City and ADUG as victims. 

Abu Dhabi, and by extension the UAE, basically now have millions of online warriors who will go out to battle for them, who will defend them no matter what they do. And that is what sportswashing is all about. 

We have also seen the success of this sportswashing already in the way UK Primer Minister Andy Burnham came out swinging for Man City’s owners. He has since had his wings clips, although there could now be political ramifications followings calls to investigate the Labour leader’s relationship with the Manchester City owners.

Having triggered the appeal, it must now take place in 12 weeks. The verdict must be delivered within 30-days of the appeal ending.

Regardless of the verdict, Man City’s online warriors will continue to fight for their owners. They will paint City and ADUG as the victims. They will claim it was always the goal to take the PL to the High Court, Supeme Court, The Hague, Nuremberg, the Earth Supreme Court or Wizengamot. And that this is all part of the bigger plan to spend millions dragging the reputation of their club through the mud.

And my final point of all this is all this posturing only deals with the sponsorship related charges. 

The claim that sponsors funding came from AD, and not ADUG, does not defend the PSR breaches, nor the lack of cooperation charges. And these alone can lead to huge point deductions, life bans for the officers and executives who failed to cooperate, and even the expulsion of Manchester City.

January 2027 will be huge. 

Keenos

Martinelli injury, Humbled Haaland and Guardiola departing

Martinelli injury

With 2 goals and 2 assists in the last 3 games, it felt like Martinelli was finally regaining his confidence and returning to form, so it is frustrating to read that he hobbled off in training yesterday for Brazil.

It is not yet clear if it was a pre-caution, or a sign of a bigger issue. What we do know is Gabi was feeling discomfort in his right calf, and he had the area strapped during training. He has since had an MRI scan.

I would be surprised if he plays against Peru, and a longer absence will be frustrating for Mikel Arteta having also seen Bukayo Saka pick up a hamstring injury for England.

What I would say is in Gabriel Jesus, Raheem Sterling and Leandro Trossard, with have 3 options who can all play outwide against Bournemouth this weekend.

If either Martinelli or Saka is not fully fit, we need to look long term and give them a week off. Following Bournemouth is Shakhtar at home followed by Liverpool away.

Without being arrogant, we should overcome Bournemouth with a front 3 of Sterling, Havertz and Jesus. Saka and Martinelli can then focus on getting fit for Liverpool.

Humbled Haaland

In Martin Odegaards absence, Erling Haaland has been wearing the captains armband.

Following last nights 5-1 defeat to Austria, the stand in captain refused to answer media questions, highlighting that great goal scorers do not necessarily make great leaders.

Players should always be angry and upset when they lose, but a captain should also be aware of his obligation to face up to defeat. Not to run away, hide and cry. Haaland is clearly not leadership material.

I have always thought that Haaland comes across is arrogant. As aloof. That everyone else is below him. And this might be what has helped him become the greatest goal scorer of his generation.

Maybe he needs to take his own advice and stay a bit more humble. Realise that defeats are part of the game. That you can not expect to win every game. And that when you do not get a positive result, you can not just throw your toys out of your pram, abuse others and hide away from your obligatins.

Guardiola departing

At the risk of becoming a Manchester City blog for the day, I want to talk about Roy Keane saying England should “go for” Pep Guardiola.

I get where Roy is coming from. England should go out for the best. But it also shows the Irishman is grasping for headlines in the same way as his pal Greame Souness. it is very clickbait of Roy to say England should go for Pep.

What I did not realise, however, is that Pep’s Manchester City contract is expiring at the end of the season, and Pep has been very coy about his future saing recently “I’ve not decided anything, everything can happen. So I don’t know. Let’s see on my future. I still need to reflect and decide what I want to do.”

Considering Jurgen Klopp’s departure from Liverpool, and Mo Salah, Virgil van Dijk and Trent Alexander Arnold are in the last season of their contract, the English football could look very different in 12 months. And a host of departures could leave the door open for Mikel Arteta and Arsenal.

Arteta has build a young squad that should stay together for the next 5 or 6 years. But we now just need to win the trophies to keep the players happy. Pep departing could put City into disarray. We are perfectly positioned to take advantage of any drop off in City’s performances over the next half a decade.

Keenos

MATCH REPORT – Arsenal 5 – 1 Bolton

Arsenal starting XI: Porter; Nichols, Kiwior,  Calafiori, Lewis-Skelly; Rice, Jorginho, Nwaneri; Saka, Sterling, Jesus.

Bolton starting XI: Southwood; Dacres-Cogley, Forino, Almeida Santos; Toal, Williams, Sheehan, Dempsey; Arfield, McAtee, Collins.

Match Officials: 
Referee: Josh Smith
Assistants: Sam Lewis and Alex James
Fourth official: Ben Toner
Carabao Cup

Emirates Stadium
Wednesday 25th September 2024
KO: 19:45 (UK)

Tonight, we look to take on League 1 opposition Bolton Wanderers in the Carabao Cup. After a great, hard working performance on Sunday, Arteta will be looking to rotate most of the squad and may look to give some of the youngsters game time.

One major talking point for tonight’s fixture, is the goalkeeper situation with Raya an injury concern and Neto cup-tied aswell as the injured Tommy Setford, 16- year old Jack Porter will have to step up to the plate. Porter had only played one game in the U-21 squad and it will be a nerve-wrecking but great experience for the youngster.

Hopefully, we can get a good cup run which we haven’t had for the past couple of years but nevertheless, our main focus is the Champions League and Premier League. 

It’s always great to see the youth players playing in the first team. Arteta speaks highly of the academy and hopefully, some more can show their quality tonight.

Bolton kicked us off and for the first couple of minutes, we held possession across the backline as Bolton kept a solid shape. Sterling managed to find himself by the byline, however some good defending from the Bolton defender won a goal kick for the away side. 

The first chance came from Bolton as a sloppy pass from Calafiori allowed the ball through to McAtee who back heeled the ball to Arfiekd who fired over from close range. As we retained possession, a couple of fouls were given away from the Bolton players as we were able to grab a corner. However, it came to nothing. 

Gabriel Jesus then had his effort blocked as Saka headed the ball onto him. Bolton then were able to get a corner of their own which was played out and in as there were a few shouts for a penalty however, the referee waved any complaints away. 

We then got the breakthrough goal as a ball across the edge of the area made it’s way to Declan Rice who took a nice touch away from the Bolton defender and whipped his effort into the bottom right corner. Bolton were here to play a physical game it seemed as a few challenges were going in from both sides. 

Bolton then won a free kick on the edge of the area as Kiwior barged the Bolton attacker. The ball was whipped in however, was cleared well. Not many attempts on goal from either side as Bolton were happy to let us keep the ball. Some nice skills from Saka allowed him to get away from the defender and slip the ball through to Jesus whose cut back was cut out by a Bolton defender . 

Quick play out from the back transitioned the ball out to Saka who played it into Nwaneri who switched the ball to Declan Rice. Rice then played the ball out to Sterling who crossed in to Jesus who tried an overhead kick which was deflected out for a corner which came to nothing. Again, we attacked as an intricate ball played from Jorginho to Saka, was well-weighted as Saka crossed into Jesus who flicked the ball just over the bar. 

Some nice passages of play from Bolton allowed themselves to the work the ball down the left-hand side as they won a corner. The ball was swung in and partially cleared by Porter as the ball rebounded back out to a Bolton player who volleyed it back in to McAtee who volleyed over. Calafiori was then booked after appearing to pull back a Bolton player. 

Bolton played the ball quickly and the cross was blocked out for a corner. Again, the ball was swung in and cleared by an Arsenal head. A nice ball through to McAtee who finished past Porter, however, the referee blew for offside. A nice ball through to Sterling in behind who whipped the ball across the box into Nwaneri who tapped home, to grab his first professional goal. 

Sterling again found himself on the byline and some good defending won us a corner, however, the referee controversially gave a goal kick for Bolton. As we continued to apply more pressure, Rice played the ball to Sterling  whose curling effort was equally matched by the Bolton keeper. 

Another ball through the Bolton backline made its way to Jesus who shrugged off the defender but fired wide. 3 minutes were then added. Sterling then went down appearing to hold his groin, however he was able to continue. Our last opportunity of the half came through a corner, as Rice’s ball was swung in and flicked on by Kiwior however, it went over everyone and the referee blew the half-time whistle.

Half time views:

A strong and well-managed first half from the senior and youth players. Two good goals from Rice and Nwaneri puts us on the front foot going into the second half.

The first 20 minutes were scrappy from both sides however, after that period we began to show our attacking prowess and comfort ability on the ball.

No changes are specifically needed for a tactical sense however, maybe taking off Saka would lift any risks. Hopefully we can keep this intensity going in the second half.

No changes were made by Arteta and we kicked off the second half. Our first chance came as Nichols overlapped Saka who played the ball through to Nichols who chipped the ball into the box and the ball was headed out for a corner. The corner was swung in by Rice and beat out by the keeper as we then were able to recycle the ball and maintain possession. 

As we looked for a breakthrough, Saka played the ball to Rice whose cross was easily claimed. However, a loose ball was pounced on by Declan Rice who played the ball through to Nwaneri whose effort snuck under the keeper and into the net for Arsenal’s third and his second of the night. 

Saka then took on Williams at left-back and fired a deflected effort into the side netting winning us a corner. The corner was swung in a cleared by Bolton who broke away as Collins went through on goal, went past Porter and tucked away. 

A nice run from Calafiori with the ball, as he played the ball across to Nwaneri who then worked the ball out to Saka whose effort was fired into the side netting. Lewis Skelly then went down requiring medical attention however, he got back on his feet. 

A few moments later, Lewis-Skelly then went down again as Arteta brought on two subs with Lewis-Skelly being replaced by Gabriel and Rice being replaced by Havertz. We then go our 4th goal of the night as some good trickery from Saka as he sat down the Bolton defender and fired the ball at the keeper as the ball rebounded out to Sterling who poked home to get his first goal in Arsenal colours. 

Another shot, this time from Calafiori who hit over with his weaker foot. We then made another two subs with Saka being replaced by Martinelli and Calafiori being replaced by Maldini Kacurri. Bolton also made a sub of their own with George Johnston replacing Chris Forino. Jesus then chipped a ball into the box which was met by Kiwior however, he couldn’t direct his header. 

A moment later, another great ball over the Bolton defence from Jorginho was met by Sterling who tried to play the ball across to Havertz however, his misplaced touch was tapped over the bar by the keeper. 

We played a short corner, which was then  clipped in by Jorginho wining us another corner. The ball was swung in and punched away to Jorginho who brought down and played the ball off to Jesus whose quick feet allowed him to glide past the Bolton players. He then played the ball off to Sterling who fired an effort at the keeper who parried the ball out to Havertz who reacted quickest and poked home past the goalkeeper to put us 5 up. 

Bolton then made two subs as McAtee and Collins were replaced by Adeboyejo and Charles. We then made another sub as Sterling , who played very well , was replaced by youngster Ismeal Kabia. A nice bit of play from Kiwior as he backheeled the ball back to Martinelli whose ball into Havertz was slightly taken with a heavy touch causing a scramble in the box as Bolton were able to clear. 

A few moments later, Jesus swung a ball in which was headed behind for an Arsenal corner. The ball was crossed in and again cleared by Santos who had played quite well in the Bolton defence. As both teams looked to settle for the score line 4 minutes were added as Bolton looked to create one last chance leaving them exposed as we won the ball back through Martinelli who won a corner. 

Nothing came from it, and Bolton had a goal kick. As the rain began to pour down, Bolton had their last chance with a corner. Jack Porter claimed the ball and the referee blew the final whistle.

Full time views:

A very complete performance, with alot of the youth team players stepping up. No player had a bad game and we were able to control the majority of the game apart from the Bolton goal.

For me, there were many standout performances such as Sterling and Saka. However, I would give the MOTM to Nwaneri , not just for his goals but for his all round performance.

Hopefully, we can build on this as we look to face Leicester again at home on Saturday.

COYG

Hudson