Tag Archives: She Wore

FA are not allowed to reward FA Cup winners with Champions League spot

2 Replies

Following Jurgen Klopp’s refusal to be in the dug out for Liverpool’s replay against League One Shrewsbury Town, the conversations have taken place about how to “restore some pride in the FA Cup”.

The most commonly heard solution that many fans and journalists propose is to “give the winners of the FA Cup and Champions League place”.

Whilst in theory, it is a good idea, the fact is UEFA regulations do not allow for it.

UEFA have a 108 page document outlining the “Regulations of the UEFA Champions League”. Article 3 outlined “Entries for the Competition”.

3.01 UEFA member associations (hereinafter associations) may enter a certain number of clubs for the competition through their top domestic championship, in accordance with the association coefficient rankings, drawn up in accordance with Annex D. No more than four clubs may qualify for the competition through each domestic championship. These rankings also determine the associations’ positions in the access list ( Annex A), which in turn determines the stage at which each club enters the competition.

3.02 Associations are represented on the following basis:

  1. one representative: winner of the top domestic championship;
  2. two representatives: winner and runner-up of the top domestic championship;
  3. three representatives: winner, runner-up and third-placed club in the top domestic championship;
  4. four representatives: winner, runner-up, third- and fourth-placed clubs in the top domestic championship.

Gone are the days when the national association could pick their own criteria and nominate who they wanted to enter UEFA competition. UEFA now dictate who can and can not qualify.

When it comes to the Champions League, the Entries for Competition is clear – all entries must come from the top domestic championship, in the order sides finished.

Previously, the runners-up of the FA Cup would qualify for the Europa League (or UEFA Cup in old money) if the winners of the competition had already qualified for Europe. This changed in 2015, switching the place to the next best placed in the Premier League.

This denied fans of Aston Villa, Crystal Palace and Wolves a place in Europe.

Like with the Champions League spots, this was to a decision made by the FA or Premier League, but one dictated to them by UEFA.

Only 104 pages in the “Regulations of the UEFA Europa League”. Again Article 3 outlines the Entries for the competition.

3.01 UEFA member associations (hereinafter associations) may enter the winner of their national cup competition (hereinafter domestic cup), as well as a certain number of other clubs for the competition through their top domestic championship, in accordance with the association coefficient rankings, drawn up in accordance with Annex D. Only one single team per club may be entered.

3.02 Associations are represented on the following basis:

  1. one representative: winner of the domestic cup;
  2. two representatives: the winner of the domestic cup and the club which finishes the top domestic championship immediately below the club which qualifies for the UEFA Champions League;
  3. three representatives: the winner of the domestic cup and the two clubs which finish the top domestic championship immediately below the club(s) which qualify for the UEFA Champions League.

3.03 In special circumstances, the winner of another official domestic competition may be entered for the UEFA Europa League in place of the lowest ranking top domestic championship representative referred to in Paragraph 3.02(c), provided such a competition has been approved by UEFA before the start of the season in question (see Annex A).

3.04 If the winner of the domestic cup qualifies for the UEFA Champions League or the UEFA Europa League via the domestic championship, the highest ranking nonqualified domestic championship club qualifies for the UEFA Europa League at the stage initially reserved for the lowest ranking top domestic championship representative. If the winner of the domestic cup qualifies for UEFA Champions League, the access stage initially reserved for the domestic cup winner is reserved for the club which finishes the domestic championship in the highest position out of all the clubs which qualify for the UEFA Europa League from the association concerned (see Annex A). In both cases each representative of the domestic championship then enters the competition at the stage initially reserved for the domestic championship representative ranked immediately above it.

So the FA and Premier League’s hands are once more tied by UEFA.

If the winner of the domestic cup qualifies for the UEFA Champions League or the UEFA Europa League via the domestic championship, the highest ranking nonqualified domestic championship club qualifies for the UEFA Europa League

UEFA have made it clear

Champions League places are rewarded on league position
Domestic cup runners up may not enter the Europa League

Keenos

Match Report: AFC Bournemouth 1 – 2 Arsenal

Leave a reply

AFC Bournemouth (0) 1 Arsenal (2) 2
FA Cup Fourth Round
The Vitality Stadium (Dean Court), Boscombe, Bournemouth BH7 7AF
Monday, 27th January 2020. Kick-off time: 8.00pm

(4-2-3-1) Emiliano Martínez, Hector Bellerin, Shkodran Mustafi, Sokratis Papastathopoulos, Bukayo Saka; Mattéo Guendouzi, Granit Xhaka; Nicolas Pépé, Joe Willock, Eddie Nketiah; Gabriel Martinelli.
Substitutes: Bernd Leno; Dani Ceballos, Alexandre Lacazette, Mesut Özil, Lucas Torreira, Ainsley Maitland-Niles, Rob Holding.
Scorers: Bukayo Saka (5 mins), Eddie Nketiah (25 mins)
Yellow Cards: Granit Xhaka
Referee: Martin Atkinson
Attendance: 10,308

And so, back to The Vitality Stadium for the second time in five weeks; let’s hope that tonight is a better match than Boxing Day’s clash, and we walk away with a passage to the fifth round, the reward being a meeting with Portsmouth at Fratton Park. But first things first; we have the matter of beating AFC Bournemouth at their ground this evening. Our intent to win this game came after just five minutes, when FA Cup debutant Bukayo Saka opened the scoring with a blistering shot (after a deft assist via Gabriel Martinelli) from just outside the six-yard box into the roof of the Bournemouth net. With a goal advantage, we started to be a little casual in our desire to control the match; there were times in the first quarter of an hour that we appeared to be the only team on the pitch tonight. Joe Willock was desperately unlucky not to score when Mark Travers made a good save with his feet to halt a certain goal, and our confidence was such that when Gabriel Martinelli carelessly blasted the ball high over the Bournemouth bar and into the crowd, nobody seemed to be too perturbed. Eddie Nketiah scored a simple tap-in after an assist by Bukayo Saka after twenty-five minutes; again, a ridiculous heart-stopping VAR period occurred when it looked as if the goal would be chalked off for an earlier offside infringement by Gabriel Martinelli. Thankfully, sense prevailed and the goal stood. And so it should as well. Arsenal were pretty much running the show in all areas on the pitch, and by now it started to look like a training match for us. The home side were poor and showed little or no desire to make their mark in the first half at all; in fact when they did finally have a shot on our goal in the thirty-sixth minute, it was comfortably parried by Emiliano Martínez. Despite one or two half-hearted attempts by the home side just before the break, the sense of relief around the stadium became evident when the half-time whistle blew.

The second half opened with the same game management order as before, only with a little more scrappier behaviour from both sets of players. The Cherries decided to actually turn up now, making some spirited attempts on our goal, but our defenders were not particularly too troubled by any threats. On the hour, Shkodran Mustafi (who had a decent game tonight) was carried off with an ankle injury, and was replaced by Rob Holding, who got into the swing of things soon enough. Although the game was becoming more competitive, we certainly held our own, and as the minutes went ticking by, our possssion game become more important than ever before. Hector Bellerin went down with an injury that left him winded, and with ten minutes left, a Ryan Gosling shot on the Arsenal goal looked more dangerous than it actually was. Following some injuries to both sides, eight minutes injury time was added on to the ninety minutes, but not before Joe Willock was replaced by Ainsley Maitland-Niles to shore up things in the added-on time period. Mattéo Guendouzi was unlucky not to score with a shot that went over the bar, but somehow, out of nowhere, Sam Surridge got one back for the home team with a half-chance that got lucky, when our defenders were asleep. Due to the usual ridiculous VAR hold-ups and hang-ups, the final whistle was blown after ten minutes injury time, and mightily relieved we were too.

This match will surely be remembered (if at all, that is) as the 100-minute match; only because VAR shenanigans kept pushing extra minutes onto the final tally. However, despite a sluggish match, we really weren’t threatened that much, even in the second half, when the home side started to take the game to us more. The highlights for us was the link-up play between the players, excellent game management, and the sheer will and determination of our young players that ultimately saw us through to the fifth round. Dare we dream? Remember everyone, keep the faith, get behind the team and the manager, as this season is going to be crucial for our future success in all competitions. Stick with the winners. Next match: Burnley at Turf Moor on Sunday, 2nd February at 2.00pm. Be there, if you can. Victoria Concordia Crescit.

Steve

Too Dearly Loved To Be Forgotten: Arsenal v Racing Club de Paris 1930-1962 by Steve Ingless (Rangemore Publications, ISBN 978-1-5272-0135-4) is now available on Amazon.

 

I LOVE the FA Cup (just a pity foreign managers are trying to destroy it)

4 Replies

I love the FA Cup.

For me it will always be the greatest cup competition on earth.

I grew up in the 90s (was born mid-80s) in a working class family in North-East London. We did not have the money for Sky TV. That meant the only football I got to watch was the FA Cup.

It was actually the FA Cup that made me fall in love with The Arsenal.

Watching the FA Cup semi-final between Arsenal and Tottenham in 1991 as a 6-year-old, I had decided to support whoever loses (I grew up in a family with little interest in football). 6-year-old me’s favourite colour was also red, so I was hoping Arsenal would lose so that I could support them.

I do not remember the game but Arsenal lost, and from that moment I became an Arsenal fan.

My next real memory of Arsenal was the 1993 FA Cup Final.

Back in those days the FA Cup Final was an all day event. The BBC would start off in the teams hotel for breakfast, live broadcast the coaches going into the stadium players on the pitch and so on.

I remember being in my kit, going out to the garden to kick a balloon pretending I played for Arsenal – no player in particular. At this point in my life the only connection I had with Arsenal was the kits I was bought. From memory I had never watched another game on TV since 1991, and did not know the players.

It finished 1-1. I do not remember watching the replay. It was past my bedtime.

The 1994 European Cup Winners Cup followed and that was it, I was hooked. But it all came from the FA Cup.

My love affair with the competition leads me to being extremely offended with the way managers, the media and the FA themselves treat the competition.

For as long as I can remember, people have questioned “the magic of the cup” and talked about its decline. But clubs, TV companies and the authorities are killing it themselves.

Tonight we play Bournemouth away. We will get some obnoxious pundit talking about the demise of the cup, whilst ignoring the fact that playing a game on a Monday night is part of the problem.

In recent years we have seen more games then ever be played on a Friday night, Saturday lunch time and Saturday afternoon.

3rd round FA Cup day used to be a day out. Sit in the pub with a huge accumulator watching the 3o’clock kick offs come in. With them now spread out over 4 days, it just is not the same.

The FA have removed the European place for the runners-up (if the winners had already qualified through the league). No longer will you get Millwall having a favourable run and going on a European tour.

A place in Europe was a well deserved prize for a lesser club if they had made it through to the final only to face and lose to one of the big boys.

The change happened from 2016, which denied Crystal Palace fans a European tour. Likewise Watford last year; thrashed in the final, no European football to help drown their sorrows.

For clubs like Palace and Watford, a cup run was their best chance of European football. Hull City, Stoke City, Cardiff City & Southampton have all qualified for Europe in recent years having finished runners-up in the cup. By removing the chance of getting into Europe as losing finalists, the FA enforce the view that survival in the Premier League is more important.

We then have the clubs themselves.

I have no issues with managers but out changed XIs in the cup. They have a squad of 25 players. It is there job to shuffle the pack and use them how they see fit. And with the top 6 especially, they have a wage bill of hundreds of millions and a squad filled with internationals.

What I can not stand is the (usual foreign) managers moaning about the cup.

We have Jurgen Klopp and Pep Guardiola recently moaning about replays. About how England should scrap either the League Cup or FA Cup.

I am sorry, but these are foreign men who simply do not get English football. They want to come here, be paid millions, but then change the things that the fans love. If they do not want replays, if they do not want 2 domestic cups, maybe stick to managing in Spain?

Klopp yesterday talked about how in the replay against Shrewsbury Town he will be putting out the U23 team and Neil Critchley, the U23 manager will be taking charge.

Liverpool have a squad that is paid £264million. It contains over 20 players capped by their country.

Klopp put out a team that contained experience centre backs Joel Matip and Dejan Lovren; behind them was Adrian in goal. Fabinho, Takumi Minamino & Divock Origi were also in the team.

An experienced team, they were 2-0 up against Shrewsbury Town – 16th in League One. They drew 2-2. Mo Salah, Firminho and Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain were all bought on to try and grab a winner.

Instead of deflecting and moaning about replays, Klopp should be calling out the performance of his own players who let a 2-0 lead slip.

Shrewsbury Town’s wage bill is just £3.5million. That is less than what most Liverpool players earn. The youngsters who started for the Scousers will also be on more money than any Shrewsbury Town player.

Liverpool might have already played 37 games this season; but Shrewsbury Town have played 36.

Whichever way you look at it, Klopp has no excuses over his side drawing against Shrewsbury. And his post-game comments shows that he just does not get the magic of the cup. It is no wonder that Liverpool have never made it past the 5th round under Klopp with his attitude.

And it is an awful attitude.

My problem with the likes of Klopp and Guardiola is these are not men who going to spend decades in the English game. Both will soon move on to their new paymasters. But whilst they are here, they are determined to wreck the greatest cup competition on earth. It just is not right.

If you can not respect the country you are living in, its customs, then maybe you should find another country.

Scrapping replays, letting the U23 manager take change, it is damaging in the long term.

The FA Cup is why I fell in love with football. It builds greater bonds for the children of Shrewsbury, Oxford and Exeter to their local club. Taking them out of the grasp of those super clubs that are hundreds of miles away.

A replay against Liverpool at Anfield will earn Shrewsbury Town in the region of £1million. It will mean a new training ground, or a new stand. It will transform the club. Transform the town.

But Klopp is sitting there in his ivory tower earning himself more money than Shrewsbury’s annual turnover, commenting about English football and English competitions. It shows he just does not understand.

Liverpool fans should call out Klopp. Make it clear that they do not agree with his stance. Likewise if Guardiola, Mikel Arteta or Jose Mourinho make disparaging comments, fans of Manchester City, Arsenal and Chelsea should make it clear that they disagree.

The FA Cup is the fans competition. From non-league to Premier League. If you do not understand its importance in English football, then you do not understand English football.

Yesterday we were informed that Yogis Warrior had sadly passed away. Stuart wrote A Cultured Left Foot. He was one of the best bloggers out there and inspired many others to “pick up a pen”. He wrote for years because he loved Arsenal. RIP, thoughts with his family.

Keenos