Tag Archives: She Wore

Exposed: Chelsea’s Financial Problems

We are now self sufficient Chelsea fans cried after showing a pre-tax profit of £13,113,000 in their 2017 accounts.

What was not made clear was this was simply clever accounting. And this week it has been exposed how dangerous having a single owner that you rely on to keep a club afloat and moving forward can be.

On Thursday, Chelsea’s Russian billionaire owner Roman Abramovich put the club’s stadium plans on hold. Chelsea issued a statement saying the club had delayed work on Stamford Bridge because of “the current unfavourable investment climate”.

This comes on the back of delays to Abramovich’s renewal of his UK visa, which expired earlier this year.

The delay in issuing him a new visa comes amid increased diplomatic tensions between London and Moscow after the poisoning of former Russian spy Sergei Skripal in Salisbury.

And those delays have since led to him cancelling his visa application.

Rumours are that Abramovich is unwilling to invest in a major project in a country where he is not allowed work.

The new stadium has been hit with problems over the years, with the estimated cost for a new 60,000 seat Stamford Bridge increasing to £1bn after delays, which included a disputes with local residents.

The club added added: “No further pre-construction design and planning work will occur. The club does not have a time frame set for reconsideration of its decision.”

The fact that the decision to pull the plug was made by one man, Roman Abramovich, shows what a precarious position Chelsea are in.

When the Russian first took over, way back in 2003, I remember the discussions on the message boards.

“What will happen if he gets bored?”

“What will happen if Putin takes him out?”

“What will happen if the money disappears as quickly as it came?”

The answer to all was simple. Chelsea would be in a lot of trouble.

No one was saying that issues would happen soon. Abramovich had moved to London and seemed happy. His family lived here, and he owned numerous houses throughout Kensington and Chelsea.

His 2007 divorce saw him give his ex wife £1bn and four houses throughout the world, including an £18 million Sussex estate.

Over his 15 years a the club, he has bankrolled Chelsea to the tune of £1bn. A few years back, those loans were reportedly written off by Abramovich, but under a complex structure, he is stil lowed nearly £1bn.

A look at Chelsea’s accounts shows how much trouble they would be in if he decided to call it quits in England.

When Abramovich loaned Chelsea the money, he did not loan it direct to Chelsea Football Club Limited (the Companies House registered limited company that deals with the football side of the business). He instead loaned it to Chelsea Limited, the group holding company.

This loan was then passed from Chelsea Limited to Chelsea PLC – the company that runs Chelsea Football Club Limited as well as Chelsea Football Club Women Ltd, The Hotel at Chelsea Limited and various other companies related to the non-football side of the business.

Chelsea Limited was renamed Fordstam Limited in 2009 – when Abramovich reportedly wrote off the debt that Chelsea owned him. This meant that whilst recapitalisation of loans happened at the level of Chelsea FC PLC, it did not happen within the holding company (Fordstam).

So whilst Chelsea FC PLC do not owe anyone £1bn, the overall group holding company Fordstam Limited have horrendous financials.

Fordstam Limited’s accounts are so bad that they do not actually get a credit limit. A recent credit search on them showed “cash transactions only”.

Underneath Chelsea PLC is the football business, Chelsea Football Club Limited. This is the trading name of the real club, having been established in 1985. Chelsea FC PLC was established in 1990 (originally named Chelsea Village) to oversee both the football club, and the surrounding “village” that was built around Stamford Bridge under Ken Bates.

Chelsea Football Club Limited is in equally as bad shape. They get just a £500 credit limit. That is not a typo. They basically get the same credit as a teenager at University.

As a comparison, the Arsenal Football Club Public Limited Company – which is the equivalent of Chelsea Football Club Limited in terms of that is the company which oversees the football side of Arsenal – gets a £47,100,000 credit limit.

In between Fordstam Limited and Chelsea Football Club Limited is Chelsea FC PLC. As explained, this is the company that owns Chelsea Football Club Limited, and other companies such as the hotel. This is the only major company within the complex structure that gets a credit limit, but in football terms this is not huge

Again, for a comparison, Arsenal Holdings PLC gets £22,000,000.

When you delve deeper into the accounts of all 3 companies involved in the running of Chelsea, you get an understanding of just how problematic things will be if Abramovich decides “enough is enough” and walks away.

Chelsea’s accounts do show a profit last year of about £15m, but this was mainly driven by player sales. A £50m loss turned around due to the sale of Oscar to China.

In their next accounts (up until June 2018) that will be announced later this year, it will once again show a huge operating loss, bought back to break even due to player sales – they raised over £100m last summer.

It means that Chelsea are in the situation where they even need another injection of cash from Abramovich or need to continue to sell to buy.

The club is on the verge of breaking down.

The likes of Eden Hazard and Thibaut Courtois want out. Both had team mates begging them to stay in their post-game interviews after the FA Cup. The sale of both will be key to raising finance to ensure the books stay even. In 2019, Chelsea will once more post an operating loss before player sales, especially with lack of Champions League football.

If they fail to sell either Hazard or Courtois, they will struggle to invest in the playing side of the club, unless they are comfortable posting an pre-tax loss. Clearly recent actions by Abramovich show that he does not want either Chelsea Football Club Limited or Chelsea FC PLC to make a pre-tax loss. He does not want to put any more of his own cash into the club.

Add in the future of Antonio Conte, the cost that it will be to get rid of him and his coaching staff – and the problems at Chelsea are really starting to mount up.

Abramovich might use the situation with his UK visa to get out of the club. He has two options that I can see.

The first is to liquidate Fordstam Limited. This is the holding company that oversees the entire group structure. This will then lead to administrators coming in to sell off parts of the club. It will be one of them £1 deals that happen in the lower leagues (and I think how Ken Bates originally bought the club).

Administration would see points deduction and potential relegation for the Premier League. The debt would disappear and what would be left is the football club. Players contracts will be considered null and void, allowing them to leave on a free.

A new owner would come in and have to rebuild from the bottom up, like we have seen with Leeds.

Alternatively, before putting Fordstam Limited into administration, Abramovich could sell Chelsea FC PLC.

Chelsea FC PLC carries no debt, but high costs.

A new owner would be unlikely to want to spend big on such a loss making enterprise, one which he might have to pump £50m a year into to ensure it stays afloat. I would be surprised if Abramovich gets much for the club if he decides to sell due to its poor financials.

If he sells Chelsea FC PLC, the club does not enter administration, it does not lose points, players or gets relegated. It just needs an owner with deep pockets willing to service the debt.

Once sold, Abramovich will send Fordstam Limited into administration, with its £1bn debt.

Some might claim “Abramovich will not want to write off £1bn”, but he is a man worth £10bn. Remember, he was happy giving his ex-wife £1bn and 4 houses!

Abramovich has always had a questionable background with links to the KGB and Russian government. Abramovich was the first person to originally recommend to Yeltsin that Vladimir Putin be his successor as the Russian president.

His friendship with Boris Berezovsky saw him purchase numerous companies after the break up of the Soviet Union for “25 times less than the market price”.

He strikes me as the type of man that will do things on the whim, and out of spite.

Whatever happens with the future of Chelsea and Abramovich, one thing is clear. Arsenal fans would be crazy to wish for Alisher Usmanov to take over at Arsenal and be subject to a single mans control, relying on him financially.

Keenos

Arsenal’s underachievers to be reunited

September 2007, Arsenal had just completed their first season at the new ground. Thierry Henry had just left for Barcelona. Freddie Ljungberg to West Ham. A year earlier Dennis Bergkamp had retired, Robert Pires was released, Sol Campbell, Lauren and Ashley Cole sold. The invincible’s were no more.

Stan Kroenke was seizing full control, but Arsenal were struggling financially.

Alisher Usmanov had bought out David Dein a month earlier. He came with a promise of Roman Abramovich style spending.

With the transfer window slamming shut, with Arsenal having signed Lukas Fabianski, Eduardo, Bacary Sagna and Lassana Diarra, Arsene Wenger uttered the immortal words:

“We don’t sign superstars, we make them”.

That season, a team was being built around a 20-year-old Cesc Fabregas. Alongside him in midfield was 23 year-old-Frenchman Mathieu Flamini. The squad was filled with players under the age of 25.

Robin van Persie (24), Gael Clichy (22), Sagna (24), Emmanuel Adebayor (23), Nicklas Bendtner (19), Theo Walcott (18), Emmanuel Eboue (24), Alex Song (20), Denilson (19), Eduardo (24), Diarra (22), Philippe Senderos (22) & Abou Diaby (21) represented one of the best young squads in England.

They were supplemented with the experience of William Gallas, Kolo Toure, Gilberto Silva, Alex Hleb and Tomas Rosicky.

The plan was obvious.

Bringing through so many young players at the same time would bread success in the future. It might not be in the first year, but as time went on, they would progress and improve as a team until they became champions – a bit like Manchester United’s class of ’92.

With Henry gone, we saw the greater good of the collective as 16 different goal scorers and togetherness made Arsenal contenders.

A strong start to the season saw Arsenal top the league table by September. It was not until December did the team lose in the league for the first time, away at Middlesbrough.

It was at the turn of the year that things went down hill.

Thrashed by Spurs 5-1 in the League Cup semi-final in January and knocked out of the FA Cup in mid-February 4-0 clearly rattled the emotionally inexperienced side.

7 days after that defeat against Manchester United, Arsenal travelled to Birmingham. A trip that would begin our downfall.

A career-threatening injury to Eduardo against Birmingham City followed up by Birmingham equalising from the penalty spot in the 95th minute – which was never a penalty coincided with the team going on a run of four draws in the Premier League.

Club captain William Gallas sat sulking in the centre circle whilst the penalty was taken, a show of petulance from the senior professional that was supposed to guide his young team mates.

Just 1 win in the next 8 games saw Manchester United soon overtook them Arsenal. Defeat to Chelsea in March moved Arsenal down in third place, where they remained at the end of the season. The spell also saw Arsenal go out of the Champions League at the quarter final stage to Liverpool.

Arsenal finished just 4 points behind eventual winners Manchester United. It was probably the last time we truly challenged for the league title,

Despite the disappointment of finishing the season without a trophy, there was plenty of be excited.

Here was a team of young players challenging for the title before their time. The project was clear and obvious. If we could keep this talented group of youths together, it was only a matter of time before they became champions.

Sadly the 2007/08 season would be this squads high point and Arsenal would not finish the next 7 seasons above 3rd.

First Flamini then Hleb, followed by Adebayor and Toure to the nouveau riche Manchester City. They were followed by Senderos, Gallas and Eduardo.

The dagger was put through the heart of the talented squad in 2011 when Samir Nasri (who signed in 2008) & Clichy joined Manchester City. Cesc went to Barcelona and Eboue to Galatasaray. That season Arsenal would be defeated by Birmingham City in the League Cup.

The departure of Robin van Persie and Alex Song within 3 days during the summer of 2012 left just Tomas Rosicky from what should have been a golden generation of Arsenal players.

And it is the Czech Mozart that sees many of the squad reunited on the 9th June for his testimonial at Prague’s Letna Stadium.

Fabregas and Kieran Gibbs, Flamini and Hleb, and Robin van Persie have already been named in a Czech Legends v Rest of the World match. Petr Cech is set to play for the Czech’s.

More players are still to be announced, and I imagine more will be from that underachieving squad that came together in 2008.

We were so close to create a team of stars. Up against the likes of Manchester City, Manchester United and Chelsea who were buying stars. Rosicky never quite stayed fit enough to be a big enough influence within the squad.

Who knows what we would have achieved had he been able to stay fit?

Keenos

She Wore a Yellow Ribbon’s Fansbet

For over 5 years, She Wore a Yellow Ribbon have partnered Islington Boxing Club as our chosen charity. We have supported them in numerous ways; including donations, sponsorship and support of their events.

Since 2017, we have raised over £1,500 for the Archway based club and other charities that we support.

We are delighted to announce that alongside our usual support, we have partnered with FansBet, a unique betting company who donate 50% of the net losing bets to charity.

Unlike with other betting affiliates, like those big Twitter accounts who link up with Ladbrokes, Bet365, etc and profit as individuals from the total losses, She Wore a Yellow ribbon do not make a penny from partnership.

We are not encouraging anyone to bet more, we just ask you to consider using Fansbet (please bet responsibly) as 50% of the total losses will 100% be donated directly to Islington Boxing Club.

Fansbet recently donated £10,000 to Shrewsbury Town as part of a crowd funding initiative which saw the club get one step closer to being the first club in England & Wales to introduce safe standing at their Montgomery Waters Meadow stadium.

It is just one example as to how fans and the betting company can work in conjunction to support local causes.

Alongside supporting the Islington Boxing Club, fans will also get exclusive enhanced off on football and boxing chosen by those who sign up.

Step 1 – Sign up here https://www.fansbet.com/en/home

Step 2 – Choose Arsenal

Step 3 – Choose “She Wore A Yellow Ribbon”

It takes 2 minutes to sign up.

As usual the support of those loyal to SWAYR and Islington Boxing Club is vital for this and will raise much needed funds for Islington Boxing Club.

Thank you

Gav