Arsenal loan watch – End of season summary

Over the course of the season we had 32 players go out a combined 38 loan spells, with 6 players being loaned to 2 different clubs.

So how did these players get on? And what does the future hold for them at Arsenal? Don’t worry, we will not be running through all 32 players! We are only going to have a look at 15 of the most senior players…

Ainsley Maitland-Niles – Southampton

Was part of the Southampton squad that got relegated. In and out of the team and only ended up starting 13 games. Completed 90 minutes on just 9 occasions. Victim of his own versatility, playing central midfield, left back and right back. 

Future – Turns 26 in August and with his contract expiring, it is unlikely he or Arsenal will have any interest in renewing. Arsenal blocking the £20million move to Wolves in 2020 looks a huge mistake.

Albert Sambi Lokonga – Crystal Palace

Started 5 Premier League games on the spin following his January move to Crystal Palace. Began to look like a decent player. The Patrick Vieira was sacked and he was rarely seen again under Roy Hodgsen. Failed to make a start as Roy led Palace to 5 wins from their last 10 games.

Future – Worrying that he fell out of the Palace team coincided with their upturn in form. Unlikely to be part of Mikel Arteta’s plans. Ideally we would like to sell him in the summer, but might have to settle for another loan. Probably to Burnley.

Arthur Okonkwo – Crewe Alexandra and Sturm Graz

Highly rated 21-year-old goalkeeper started every league game for 3rd tier Crewe before Arsenal recalled him in January. Then sent straight out to Sturm Graz where he was first choice in the Austrian Bundesliga. Conceded 53 goals in 44 games across both loan spells, keeping 16 clean sheets.

Future – Arsenal need to make a decision on Okonkwo and Karl Hein. Both are 21 and a similar level. Both home-grown. One will be kept and the other probably loaned out again.

Auston Trusty – Birmingham City

Became a fan favourite, starting 44 out of 46 Championship fixtures. Performances led to first call up for the United Statesand his value skyrocket. 

Future – Possibly found his level in the Championship. Might do a job at a lower end of the Premier League. Expect Arsenal to sell and make a good profit on their £1.5million investment.

Brooke Norton-Cuffy – Rotherham and Coventry

Played regularly for Rotherham at the start, but found himself in and out of the team towards the end, starting just 5 of his last 11 Championship games. In the space of 24 hours, Arsenal recalled him and sent him to Coventry. Started 17 time as Coventry made the play-offs. Also started all 3 playoff games including their final defeat to Luton. The attacking right back spent much of his time playing right wing / right wing back at both clubs.

Future – Still only 19. The concern will be is he is a traditional right back who likes to get up and down the touchline, and is not suitable to Arteta’s inverted demands. Reuell Walters has potentially jumped ahead of him in the pecking order. Plenty of Premier League club’s will be looking at Norton-Cuffy. Could see him as a long-term replacement for Kieran Trippier at Newcastle.

Cédric Soares – Fulham

Disappointing loan spell at Fulham saw him start just twice for the West London club. Came off the bench on 4 occasions.

Future – Turns 32 in August with a year left on his contract, I would be surprised if Arsenal can get anyone to take on his wages. Question is whether he has the ambition to play, or is happy staying at Arsenal and being paid a few million to turn up to training.

Charlie Patino – Blackpool

Started off brightly for Blackpool in a new deeper role, but his form tailed off as his loan-club hurtled towards relegation. Still struggles to impose himself in games and looks to be still struggling with the step up from youth football to senior.

Future – Having seen his former teammates move abroad, play regular top flight football and become established international stars, it is no surprise he is looking for a move away from Arsenal. Germany beckons.

Folarin Balogun – Reims

20 goals in 36 Ligue 1 games is impressive, with Balogun outscoring Lionel Messi as the headline. But that needs to be offset with Alexandre Lacazette scoring 7 more than him. And we all know Laca struggled for goals in the Premier League – never scoring more than 14. Only Lionel Messi had a worse shot to goal conversion rate (FB: 20%) in the top flight of French football, and Balogun had the 2nd worst shot accuracy of France’s top 10 gal scorers. Just 2 assists shows that when he was not scoring, he was not contributing much else.

Future – Balogun wants assurances of first team football at Arsenal, something which the underlying stats behind the goals show he is not ready for. Reminds me of Andy Cole in that he needs a lot of chances to score. Expect him to get a big money move elsewhere where he will grab himself 10-15 goals a season. Balogun is the level of a Tammy Abraham or Dominic Solanke.

Marquinhos – Norwich City

After spending the first half of the season acclimatising to England, the Brazlian was loaned out to Norwich City. A goal and assist on his Championship debut promised a lot, but they would be his only goal contributions in his 8 starts.

Future – Needs another Championship loan, and to play regularly for a full season. Can see him at one of the recently relegated clubs.

Miguel Azeez – Ibiza and Wigan

Recalled from the party island in January, Azeez would start his first two games for Wigan under Kolo Toure prior to the former-Arsenal man being sacked. New Wigan manager Shaun Maloney called on Azeez to “to train hard, be a good team-mate and fight for his spot in the 18”, and Azeez would fail to even appear in the bench again. This led Azeez’s dad to comment “the new manager came in and hasn’t really trusted him, which has been disappointing.”

Future – Questions have to be asked about those Maloney quotes. Was Azeez not training hard enough? What does he mean by “be a good team-mate”. Has no future at Arsenal.

Nicolas Pepe – Nice

Started off well for Nice with 6 goals in his first 15 league games. A knee injury then disrupted his season before he was left out of the squad for the last 7 games of the season. Played 19 league games in total for Nice. Maybe there was a clause in his contract where they had to pay a bit more after he played 20 times in the league?

Future – Two years left on his contract, if Arsenal can find a buyer willing to pay over £20million, he will be off.

Nuno Tavares – Marseille

Made headlines with 3 goals in his first 4 games for Marseille. But that hid the fact that he was poor defensively. Ending up playing more as a winger than a left back, his erratic play led him to being unpredictable and inconsistent. Ended up falling out with Marseille coaching staff for not working hard enough.

Future – One of those that falls under the label “how is an opponent supposed to know what he is doing if he does not”.Marseille seem to have little interest in making the loan deal permanent. Not good enough for Arsenal.

Pablo Marí – Monza

Second loan spell in Italy. Was caught up in an attack in Milan which saw one man died. The World Cup break gave him the time to recover and play a key part as Monza finished 8th.

Future – A good player who simply became surplus to requirements as we signed a better player (Gabriel). A £6million is already reportedly be done to make the loan move permanent.

Runar Alex Runarsson – Alanyaspor

24 starts in the Turkish Super Lig. He started all but 2 games for Alanyaspor, who finished 11th. Oddly missed their final game due to a suspension having picked up too many yellow cards for time wasting.

Future – Found his level playing in a lesser league for a lesser team. Arsenal contract expires in a year. Will probably be loaned out again rather than sold.

Tyreece John-Jules – Ipswich Town

3 goals in 17 games for Ipswich Town. An injury in October saw him return to Arsenal and miss out on Ipswich’s promotion drive.

Future – Now 22, the 4-year deal he signed in 2019 is due to expire this summer. Arsenal will continue allowing him to use the services of their medical facilities until he is fit enough to find a new club.


Summary

The loan system is important for players development. It shows whether they are ready to step up and become part of the first team or are simply not good enough and should be sold on.

Some players found their level and will go on to have good careers. Others might have to rebuild their careers at an even lower level.

The two most of us kept an eye on – Patino and Balogun –had contrasting seasons. 

Patino showed he is a long way from regular top levelfootball, whilst Balogun showed he is well on the way to fulfilling his potential.

The club probably would have liked the pair to have one more season on loan prior to a decision being made on them in 24, but both seem to want to move this summer.

All those mentioned on this list will be sold (bar Marquinhos) if the right offer comes in. And then it is on to focusing on the next generation. 

Keenos

Arsenal linked with half a dozen players in 24 hours as silly season begins…

The 2022/23 season is not even cold yet and transfer silly season has already began.

The Declan Rice talk has been non-stop since Christmas. The latest rumour being that the two clubs are a long way apart on valuation, but the deal would probably happen.

Then we have Moises Caicedo. Apparently Brighton expect Arsenal to pay the fee. Whatever that is.

Elye Wahi is a new name to me. Google shows he scored 17 league goals in Ligue 1 last season. 3 less than Folarin Balogun.

Next up it is Arda Guler. Nope. Me neither.

We are also chasing Leeds United’s Wilfried Gnonto and Brazilian “wonderkid” Marcos Leonardo.

Then there is the talk of William Saliba’s wage demands “shocking” the Arsenal board.

And all of this in the last 24 hours.

With fees quoted, I make it over £300m spent by Arsenal on the 6 players mentioned above. At least we will recoup some of it when we sell Saliba to whoever we will be linked with today.

How about we get involved in a bit of fun? Vote Arsenal for biggest overachievers this season.

We used to be the kings of Twitter polls, but Newcastle look to have taken that crown in recent months.

Winning a poll means nothing. But it is just a bit of fun! At the time of posting we only had 35% of the vote.

Enjoy your Thursday. It really is going to be a long summer…

Keenos

Arsenal player ratings – 2022/23

Aaron Ramsdale – 8/10
41 games, 0 goals

Aaron Ramsdale has had a fantastic season and he continues to grow. Only Ederson and Alisson are probably ahead of him in the league – he is in a group including Jordan Pickford, Nick Pope and David Raya fighting to be “best of the rest”.

Ramsdale saved us with fantastic saves on many occassions this season, and his errors are lapses of concentration have been almost eradicated. His distribution has been excellent.

Matt Turner – 5/10
7 games, 0 goals

A tough first season for Matt Turner and at times he looked shakey. Reluctant to mark him down too much as he just did not play much, and when he did it was infront of a defence that did not play together much. Many of the problems were down to communication.

Teams are moving away from the “two top keepers” model, with one playing the league and the other in the cups. The return to a single keeper playing in almost every game (when fit) makes it that bit harder to recruit a quality number 2. Turner does a job.

Karl Hein – unranked
1 game played, 0 goals

Played once, slipped, gave away a penalty, conceded 3. Only 21 and home grown (I think). Would be unfair to mark him out of 10 based on a single performance.

Ben White – 8/10
46 games played, 2 goals

Was expected to play a duel role of back-up right back and back-up centre back. Ended up as first choice central defender.

Solid in defence, he also built up a great relationship going forward with Bukayo Saka. Lack of pace very rarely exposed. Tired towards the end of the season. But everyone did.

Takehiro Tomiyasu – 4/10
31 games played, 0 goals

Was suprised how many games Tomi ended up playing. But over half were off the bench – he only played 19% of the total minutes. Some might consider the 4 to be unfair, but I have factored in the injuries.

Missed half of the season injured, and that on the back of him missed much of last season. Clearly a talent and will be back up right back and left back next season. But needs to get fit and stay fit.

Cedric Soares – 2/10
4 games played, 0 goals scored

Forgot he played for us. And I think Fulham forgot he played for them. Has one-year left on his deal. Expect a season long loan to be on the cards.

Gabriel Magalhães – 9/10
48 games played, 3 goals

Has to be in the discussion for Arsenal player of the season.

Started every Premier League game and missed just 9 Premier League minutes in total. Is a consistent performer and provides some steel at the back. Always up for the physical battle. Claims that he is “error prone” is just lazy punditry. One of the best in the league.

William Saliba – 8/10
33 games played, 3 goals

Built a fantastic partnership with Gabriel. If he stayed fit, we would have won the league. Back injury is a concern is they potentially never go away. Only reason he is marked 1 down from Gabriel is due to the injury. Need to get him signed up to a new deal.

Jakub Kiwior – 6/10
8 games played, 1 goal

Signed in January. Looks a player. Strong, quick with an eye for a pass, he will provide great cover for Gabriel in gthe coming seasons. Will also be interesting to watch him develop in that inverted full back role. He is not too disimilar to Nathan Ake.

Rob Holding – 5/10
24 games played, 2 goals

Love Rob Holding. But if we are to consistently challenge for the league, we need to be looking for someone better.

Replaced Saliba and the class difference showed. Kiwior ended up coming in for him and the Pole looked a better proposition. 7 seasons and 162 games for The Arsenal. I wish him well in the future.

Oleksandr Zinchenko – 7/10
33 games, 1 goal

Key to our form, we are a better team with him in it. Defensive lapses were due to how he was being asked to play rather than a sign of his own ability. Injury worries were raised early in the season. He has never played more games then he did this season. Needs to build on his fitness to enable himself to keep playing at a high level.

Kieran Tierney – 6/10
36 games played, 1 goal

Tough season for the Scotsman who found himself 2nd choice to Olexsander Zinchenko, and then demoted to 3rd choice as Tomiyasu got selected ahead of him. He also sat on the bench and watched whilst Jakub Kiwior was played at left back in the closing games of the season.

Tierney is a fantastic left back, but he can not play in the inverted role that Mikel Arteta demands.

Arteta refused to change the tactics when Tierney came in, which exposed him in those more central positions. This summer is possibly the right time to move him on.

Thomas Partey – 8/10
40 games played, 3 goals

Was one of our best players, and arguably the best defensive midfielder, then he ran out of steam. Huge difference between us and Manchester City is Rodri remained at the high level whilst Partey dropped off. We were clearly managing his injury issues throughout the season. Next year we need some quality alongside him who can share the minutes a bit better. One of those you want fit and firing in the business end of the season.

Granit Xhaka – 8/10
47 games, 9 goals

Easily his best season for Arsenal. Showed that many we have been playing him in the wrong position for 7 seasons. Was pushed further forward by Arteta this season – playing in a role he has excelled in for Switzerland. Shows leadership. Will be missed. But feels like it is the right time to leave.

Jorginho – 6/10
16 games, 0 goals

Questions were asked when he was signed. Claims that he was washed up and his legs were gone. Showed he has the ability to control a game at will, and gets around the pitch more than you would think.

Reminds me a little of Pirlo and Alonso. There clubs dumped them at 32, and they both continued to play at a very high level, driving their sides to league titles, for another 3-4 seasons. Luka Modric more recently shows that being an excellent reader of the game can make up for any physical decline. Will have a part to play at Arsenal next season.

Mohamed Elneny – 2/10
8 games played, 1 goal

Two long term injuries resulted in Elneny starting just 1 Premier League game. Like Holding, we now need to move on from him. Jorginho is already a step up. As will others. Got a new 1-year deal to enable us to help him get back to full fitness. Also doing his coaching badges at the club.

Albert Sambi Lokonga – 3/10
15 games, 0 goals

Suffered at Arsenal due to lack of game time. Not really a 6 but was asked to play there when Elneny got injured. Went on-loan to Crystal Palace where he looked to have found his level before finding himself out of the team. I think there is a good player in him, Arsenal just do not have the time to polish a rough diamond right now. Expect him to move on in the summer and be a consistent mid-table Premier League performer.

Ethan Nwaneri – unranked
1 game played, 0 goals

Given his debut by Arteta at just 15. Highly rated by the club but contract dispute led him to not feature again. Will leave this summer. Probably end up as quiz question.

Martin Odegaard – 9/10
45 games played, 15 goals

This is the year that Martin Odeggard fullfilled the potential that led to Real Madrid signing him as a 16 year old. The goals, the assists, the work rate, the leadership. Baffles me some still criticise him. Only Kevin de Bruyne is better in this league. Fantastic season, now needs to back it up next year.

Fábio Vieira – 4/10
33 games played, 2 goals

I am not going to go down the route of some and write him off. He certainly has not lived up to the big price tag, but Arsenal can not just keep buying £45million players just ebcause one does not settle straight away.

He has plenty of technique, but needs to add a bit more physicality. Form and fitness of Odegaard means he rarely got a sniff, and was never able to put a run of games together to gain confidence. Will need to work hard this summer to stay in Arteta’s plans. beyond next season.

Bukayo Saka – 10/10
48 games, 15 goals

No longer should we be talking about Bukayo Saka’s potential. He is World Class now. Arguably the only right winger on his level in world football is Mo Salah. The only Arsenal player that would walk into the Manchester City team. There is nothing he can not do and just gets better and better.

Gabriel Martinelli – 9/10
46 games played, 15 goals

Where Saka leads, Gabriel Martinelli follows.

With 15 goals this season, the conversation is over as to whether we need a new left winger. He is the number one and not many are better in the Premier League. Still has a level or two to go to bre on par with Saka, but the ability is there. Adds a bit of direct play to our team.

Leandro Trossard – 7/10
22 games, 1 goal

Surprised he only got a single goal. He seemed a lot more invovled than that. Although he did get 10 assists. A solid option on both the left and right hand side and should allow Arteta to give Saka and Martinelli more regular breaks next season. Also a great asset to come off the bench and try and make something happened.

Emile Smith Rowe – 2/10
14 games played, 0 goals

After being so good last season, Smith Rowe’s injuries returned. I do not think he will ever stay fit for an entire season. To challenge consistently for the title, we can not have anyone with a history of injuries. Time to cash in before that “injury prone” label sees his transfer value plummet.

Reiss Nelson – 5/10
18 games played, 3 goals

Gave us the moment of the season with that 10 seconds of greatness against Bournemouth. But that does not change the fact that he is not good enough and Mikel Arteta does not rate him. Rarely bought on by Arteta, Nelson failed to make a single Premier League start.

Trossard was signed in January and the difference between the pair was obvious. Nelson will never be the quality needed to compete for a 1st team place.

Marquinhos – unranked
6 games, 1 goal

Only just turned 20, Marquinhos was loaned out to Norwich City in January. Was in and out of their team. Probably needs another Championship loan deal. Somewhere where he can play regularly.

Gabriel Jesus – 7/10
33 games played, 11 goals

Like Zinchenko, we raised concerns over his season long fitness having been part of the Pep Guardiola rotation policy for so long. Unlucky to pick up a long term injury whilst at the World Cup.

Not the out and out goal scorer that some demand, but his fluidity across the front 3 makes us very unpredictable. We scored 88 league goals (club record), and he was a big part of that. An out and out goal scorer would not necessarily see the team score more.

Just 3 goals against the top 8 is a concern. If we want to kick on, he needs to become a bit more clinical in those bigger games.

Eddie Nketiah – 6/10
39 games played, 9 goals

Came in for Jesus when injured and did a solid job. Problem is he only plays down the middle which made us more predictable. The other concern is that he failed to score a single goal when coming off the bench (bought on 21 times). If Arsenal are behind, Eddie just is not the man to sling on and say “get us a goal”.