Tag Archives: She Wore

Officials need to stop arrogance over VAR decisions

5 Replies

Arsenal were poor on Sunday. That is not up for debate.

We were also masters of our own downfall, our errors rather than Watford’s good play leading to their 2 goals. That is also not up for debate.

But what should also not be a debate is Watford’s first goal. It should not have counted.

The new goal kick rule has led to players taking huge risks in the penalty area. We saw both Arsenal and Manchester City succumb to this over the weekend.

The new rule now dictates that the ball is in play when it is kicked and clearly moves. Previously it had to leave the penalty area before being deemed in play.

Opponents must be outside the penalty area until the ball is in play…If an opponent who is in the penalty area when the goal kick is taken, or enters the penalty area before the ball is in play, touches or challenges for the ball before it is in play, the goal kick is retaken.

The rule is clear and obvious. The goal kick should have been retaken.

Now I do not expect VAR to rule on every goal kick, but when it is a goal, surely VAR should be looking at every offence?

It is not an excuse the Tom Cleverley’s foot was a foots width inside the area. It is actually an offence for it to be on the line. It should be outside the box. Even a toenail inside is an offence.

If you think I am being “picky” then lets imagine other scenarios.

Imagine the ball went a foots width out of play before a goal was scored…VAR would rule the ball had gone out of play and the goal disallowed.

Imagine the player was a foots width offside before a goal was scored…VAR would rule the ball had gone out of play and the goal disallowed.

Imagine the ball was a foots width behind the goal…Goal line technology would rule it a goal.

On Sunday Chris Woakes took a wicket for England against Australia. He had nothing behind the line. Regardless of it being a marginal decision, the wicket was disallowed.

Cast your mind back to 2007 and the Rugby World Cup Final.

Mark Cueto scored a try, but his toe brushed the line. It was marginally, and still debated to this day. but the rules are clear. The player in possession of the ball only needs part of his body to touch the line for it to be an offence and the ball deemed out of play.

In tennis the use hawk eye. A brilliant system which shows whether the ball was in or out. If the ball is out, it is out. No debating. No argument. On with the next point.

The crux of the matter is in the lead up to Watford’s goal, Cleverley committed an offence which should have led to play being restarted with a goal kick.

It does not matter how minor the offence was, or how marginal.

In other sports it is either black or white. You have either committed an offence or have not committed an offence.

Football seems obsessed with ignoring clear and obvious offences in an attempt to support the on-field referee.

The Premier League (or FA?) dictated that VAR should on interfere if it is a “clear and obvious error”. Cleverely is in the box. It is clear and obvious.

Until the football authorities  stop with their arrogant support of referees, VAR will continue to be controversial. Will continue to be disliked.

In rugby, you often hear the referee ask “is there any reason why I should not give the try”. In cricket, they check everything from the no-ball, if it hit the bat and hawkeye for an LBW. In football it should be similar. If you are going to use VAR, it should check everything in the lead up to a goal.

It is not the fault of VAR that the decision was wrong, but the fault of those who are analysing it.

Arsenal were awful and did not deserve 3 points. But if the authorities do not want to use video replays properly, they should not use them at all.

Keenos

Matteo Guendouzi is Arsenal’s most complete midfielder

1 Reply

Recently I had a discussion with our friends over on YouAreMyArsenal about who Raul Sanllehi should be targeting to replace Granit Xhaka in the long term.

The produced this fantastic scouting report on Ibrahim Sangare; putting the 21-year-old Ivorian central midfielder as a long term replacement for Xhaka.

Whilst Sangare is a fantastic physical specimen, and would certainly add some power into the middle of the park, his passing is an issue.

Xhaka sees more of the ball than any other player at Arsenal. He is the main receiver in midfield when the ball is with the defence, and he starts most of our attacks.

On average last season in the Premier League, Xhaka averaged 77.4 passes a game. No player averaged more. He completed 85.3% of those passes.

Compare that to Sangare who averages just 49 passes a game, completing just 80.3% of them. Xhaka is completing 27 more passes a game on average than Sangare.

Xhaka’s pass completion has to be considered when we are discussing players to replace him.

Whilst it is easy to think that we need a hulking 6ft 3in monster of a midfielder who can break up play, we need that player to be able to pass the ball as he sees so much of it.

We are The Arsenal, not Stoke. A player’s ability on the ball is more important than his destructive impact. If he can not pass, he is useless for 60% of the time in the majority of our games.

At Arsenal you need to be able to pass the ball. That is highlighted in the pass competition of Arsenal’s other 2 central midfield options last season: Lucas Torreira and Matteo Guendouzi.

Last season Torreira averaged 46.8 passes a game, completing 87.4% of them. Guendouzi with 48.4 passes a game at 87.7%.

Both of these players averaged less passes per game than Xhaka, but it has to be taken into account that both came off the bench 10 times in the Premier League last season. Xhaka was averaging more minutes per game.

Xhaka still comes out on top, but the primary reason for this is Unai Emery sets up for the Swiss man to be the 1st receiver off of the defence.

If we are looking at a long term replacement for Granit Xhaka, we should look no further than someone who is already at the club. Matteo Guendouzi.

At just 20-years-old, Guendouzi has quickly established himself as a 1st team regular.

Last season he might have been outpassed by Xhaka, but we have seen him take huge strides forward again this season, including a man of the match performance against Tottenham

This season Guendouzi has completed 88.2% of his passes. A slight improvement but still an improvement.

The Frenchman has still played 2nd fiddle to Xhaka when it comes to how much of the ball they see – Xhaka is averaging an incredible 92 passes per 90 minutes this season.

In terms of his passing, Guendouzi is a more accurate passer than Xhaka, but plays less passes. As his importance to the team continues to grow, expect both of these to grow.

What has been impressive about Guendouzi this season is his defensive shift.

Whilst last season he was bottom of the table defensively, and some rightly labelled him as lazy at times, this season he has stepped up massively.

He is not too far behind Ibrahim Sangare, when it comes to defensive output. And it has to be remembered Sangare plays in a team who do a lot more defending than Arsenal (Toulouse finished 16th last season) – which also explains why Sangare’s total passes is lower.

So in Guendouzi we have a central defender who is over 6ft, whose passing is already amongst the best in the team and getting better, and who has now added a defensive awareness to his game.

Guendouzi could become the complete central midfielder. Capable of being 1st receiver and dictating the play, whilst also putting in the defensive shift of someone less cultured.

The man to replace Granit Xhaka at Arsenal is Matteo Guendouzi.

He is already better defensively than the Swiss midfielder and with time could become a better passer.

Based on the passing statistics, he is not yet ready to take over from Xhaka as 1st receiver, but his pass completion rate does excite me. He gives the ball away less than Xhaka (his biggest criticism).

Xhaka is going nowhere soon. His importance can be seen in those passing statistics. But as Guendouzi’s influence grows, Xhaka’s will naturally shrink.

It will no longer be a question as to “who should replace Xhaka” but “who should partner Guendouzi”. That man could still be Xhaka. It could also be Torreira or Joe Willock.

Guendouzi is very quickly turning into an all round central midfielder, and at 20-years-old will only get better.

Keenos

Fake news filling the void of the international break

2 Replies

This international break seems to have gone on forever. They always do. There really has not been much going on, so there has been little to write about.

Some have filled the void by spreading fake news about Arsene Wenger in talks to return to Arsenal. How a 15-year-old from India who runs one of those Twitter accounts that copy and pastes News Now headlines has inside knowledge on Arsenal I will never know.

Fact is the account in question does not have inside knowledge on Arsenal, and is merely making stuff up for RTs during the dull international break.

There has been plenty to fill the time during the break. Mainly cricket and F1. Add in Peaky Blinders and Mindhunter and there has been enough to keep myself occupied. Even used the free time to de weed my driveway.

There has been some Arsenal-related stuff going on over the last week.

We had Eddie Nketiah and Riess Nelson performing well for England U21s. Both are clearly too good for that level. But probably not quite good enough to play regular Premier League football.

Eddie has done well on loan at Leeds and, worst case scenario, Arsenal should be able to get a fee north of £20million next summer if they decide to cash in.

He is a pure finisher and needs to work on his link up play. Around the world, the top strikers are no longer just goal scorers. The likes of Sergio Aguero, Firminho, Lionel Messi and Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang also get involved in the build up play. Eddie needs to add that to his game.

On the worlds best strikers, FIFA announced their “Best” list last week. Auabameyang failed to make the list. It was not a surprise as he failed to win anything. However when you consider only 4 of the players outscored him on the list, you start to fill these things are a waste of time.

The fact that Mauricio Pochettino was named alongside Jurgen Klopp and Pep Guardiola as one of the best 3 managers last season sums it up. His Spurs side nearly lost as many games as they won.

Other stuff going on includes Grant Xhaka and paternity leave.

It is a story that has been blown out of proportion as people look to fill the international void.

His baby is due mid-October during the international break.

Xhaka’s Swiss team-mate Haris Seferovic has taken the same steps this week, leaving the squad early after becoming a father.

And Xhaka said: “There are more special things in life than football. For example, when you become a father.

“With Haris it was agreed that he gives everything against Ireland and then travels home.

“And with me, it would probably fall on that time when we play.”

He is not taking time away from Arsenal, but taking time away from the Swiss national team. There really is not much to complain about.

Tonight France play Andorra and it should see Matteo Guendouzi make his debut.

Fair play to the lad.

18 months ago he was playing in the French League 2, and now he is an Arsenal 1st team regular and about to play for his country. He has kicked on from last season and as long as he continues to progress, he could make it to the very top.

Real football returns at the weekend but before then we have more cricket!

Keenos