The recruitment of David Raya by Arsenal has been one of the most talked about transfers in decades.
Popular Aaron Ramsdale was cast aside in mid-August as Raya joined from Brentford on-loan. The result was a never ending stream of criticism from journalists, pundits and many Arsenal fans.
6 months on and Raya now looks very settled in an Arsenal jersey, and any negative comments surrounding why we signed him should be gone – although every now and again a lazy pundit likes to mention him again.
We conceded a shocker of a goal against Liverpool and this lead to those lazy pundits to repeat their misguided rhetoric.
Karen Carney, one of a new breed of pundits who are just not fit for purpose, said “the goalkeeper needs to communicate better, he can see it all, he’s under no pressure, and that’s where we question is he the right goalkeeper because he doesn’t have that commanding presence.”
Firstly, the goal was clearly not his fault.
William Saliba failed to take control of the situation and expected his keeper to come out for the ball. In leaving it for Raya, the Frenchman did not work hard enough to keep Luis Diaz behind him. The result was the calamity of an own goal for Gabriel.
I have watched the goal numerous times and fail to see how any blame goes on Raya. As a central defender, you should always be thinking “if in doubt, kick it out”.
It is clear that Raya did not call for the ball – you can see in his body language and way he did not fly out for the ball. It was Saliba’s decision that it would be “keepers” rather than Raya’s. A defender should not be making that decision for the keeper.
One thing that has impressed me with Raya is his command of the area.
When we signed him, I spoke to a Brentford fan and he informed me that Raya’s aerial prowess was one of his best attributes. He would come out in a crowded box and catch the ball under extreme pressure. Handling in the air was exceptional.
Early in his career, Raya had a couple of bloopers (Chelsea) where he was arguably in the wrong position for a cross. At the time I questioned whether this was his issue, or an issue with coaching. Since that day he has looked imperious in the air.
Only 3 players have caught the ball from more crosses this season than Raya. In comparison, he has punched the ball clea just 4 times (16th in the Premier League). So I am not really sure what Carney is going on about when she says Raya does not have a “commanding presence.”
A lot of the love for Ramsdale was over his character. He is a decent keeper who is good enough for a top 6 team. Raya has that little bit extra that could lead him to being a title winning keeper.
Take the quick throw outs as an example.
Over the years we have seen Ederson and Alisson turn defence into attack with their quick and accurate distribution (whether by feet or throwing). It is a great asset to have for a keeper in a top team as you can launch an attack with opponents having players up the field and before defenders have got back into their low block.
Raya was involved in a lot of goals for Brentford with his distribution, and I am sure this is one reason we signed him.
Having settled in the team, we are now seeing the impact of Raya. Everytime he gets the ball Gabriel Martinelli is sprinting into that space left by a full back. We have already scored once this season and against Liverpool we were unlucky not to score another.
What is interesting when watching Raya is he does not just pump it forward every time. He looks for that quick throw out and if it is not on he is happy taking a few steps back. For me this is the difference between him and Ramsdale.
Ramsdale was neither accurate enough in his distribution, or calm enough to realise the opportunity had gone. He would often just launch the ball forward, needlessly losing us possesion.
As Raya has settled, his distribution is much improved.
It was always going to take a while for him to get used to passing out to Gabriel, William Saliba, Declan Rice, etc. Understanding where they would be positioned and how they wanted the ball delivered makes all the difference when trying to draw the opponent out close to our goal ahead of launching an attack to get throug the press.
When he first joined, Raya was having to get his head up and look where he was playign the ball. This would lose vital split-seconds. Now he is playing those passes on instinct, knowing his teammate will arrive into the space he is passing into.
For me it is now a no-brainer. Raya is available for £27million in the summer and it is a move we have to make. Meanwhile, we should be looking to cash in on Ramsdale for £40million or more. Nottingham Forest, Brentford, Brighton and Newcastle look the likely destinations.
A £13million (or more) difference between the two fees will add extra to our transfer kitty this summer. Although that would likely be eaten up as we buy a new number two (someone who is happy to sit on the bench and whose dad won’t go on every podcast going).
Have a good Thursdsay.
Keenos
She Wore A Yellow Ribbon 
I disagree entirely. Raya left his goal to come towards Saliba, but then failed to go for the ball, leaving an unattended goal that resulted in Gabriel’s own goal. I don’t consider his distribution to be any better than Ramsdale’s. Yes his throw to Martinelli was brilliant, but so was Ramsdlae’s kick upfield to Nelson in the cup match against Liverpool. As for his “commanding presence “, he failed to cut off the cross that led to Newcastle’s victory earlier in the season. I could make further criticisms but this will do. Bring back Ramsdale!
LikeLike
Raya comes out and catches 15.3% of crosses. Ramsdale just 5.8%. The facts don’t back up your opinion.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, but it’s the critical saves that matter, not the statistics. As Groucho Marx said, “there are lies, lies and damn statistics.” That’s the difference between looking good and being a winner…
LikeLike
Critical saves actually mean very little in the grand scheme of things. A keeper will kick the ball, catch crosses, throw the ball, etc a lot more than he makes saves. And if the defence is fantastic (which ours is), then a keeper will have to very rarely pull off a “worldie” save at a top club>
Ederson and Alisson very rarely pull off “superman” saves. They do not need to. But what they do well is the basics in terms of coming for crosses, kicking the ball, throwing the ball and the saves you expect them to make.
LikeLike
The difference between your opinion and keenos is the lack of statistical evidence.
You opinions are heavily influenced by the eye test which can be coloured by emotions.
You like Rams. I do too. And he needs to improve his game. How that can be done without game time is my only critique of Arteta.
LikeLike
“How that can be done without game time is my only critique of Arteta” – Ramsdale is 25 years old and played over 200 games, including nearly 100 for Arsenal. I do not think lack of game time is an issue.
LikeLike